This would be a 5-star bookcase because it's very sturdy feeling.  The shelves are thick and feel heavy duty, and the color is what we expected from the pictures.  The only problem is that we ordered two of these and one had a cracked piece.  We waited for weeks to get the replacement piece, which never came.  We finally got a whole replacement bookcase, only to have two of those pieces cracked as well.  It's disappointing to go through such a hassle for a pretty quality book case.