Over all this is a nice sturdy bar stool.  I like the fact that they have steel ball bearings for the swivel.  When you sit on them and rotate the chair it is very smooth.  They go together fairly easy too.  The reason I gave them a 4 star rating was they are a little orange in color which you can't see in the picture of them.  Also, what appears to be tacks on the seat are not really tacks but rather a decorative strip.  Still they look good and function well so overall i'm happy with them.