The shelf is Gorgeous. I did not rate a 5 for a technical reasons. The E screws do not fit the top shelf. I had to stop the project during Covid 19 to go out and shop for screws. I ended up buying two inch wood screws that worked just fine. 

However, the bookcase is beautiful. It added the right element to my home office decor. The drawer doesn’t pull out all the way but it will fit things like pens/pencils staples, and etc. It’s small but cute. The finish had a nice shine but not overdone. The shelf is sturdy. I would suggest using the anchor attachment if small children are around. The instructions were straight forward but I did record a video for anyone who might need help building their shelf. You can find me at StarrLuxx by Tisha Starr! If you like the video please subscribe.