I'm leaving off a star because the color description is a little off. Sometimes people use the description of "Charcoal" as a soft black and was really hard to tell in the photo. It's definitely a dark gray and not charcoal at all. I was hoping it was more black to tie in my black and white decor but I will keep it. Looks nice. Nice crisp white. Thin but has a bit of shag pile to it. Will see how it holds up in the family room over time.