These chairs and beautiful, super heavy, and surprisingly much more comfortable then I expected. 

I took off a star for two reasons 
First, I wish the hardware on the black chairs was darker or black. The silver hardware really stands out on the chairs from all angles. 

Second, the instructions should specify which of the two similar pieces is the back vs foot brace. There’s no way to tell before you assemble and they’re different lengths - very difficult to undo if you make a mistake. Overall, assembly is pretty straight forward though hard on the hands. 

Overall, very happy with these and will be considering another set for our backyard.