Be sure to measure your couch - especially the seat cushion. This cover just fits but I have s very large & deep couch.  The reason for the rating is that although the material is very soft & comfy I have a feeling it it not as durable as I would like. Also the first one came and the zipper was broken off.  Replacement came with a hole in the seat cushion cover. Third one came with a flaw at a seam - extra material sticking out of the seam. I kept the third out of frustration and only b/c you don't see the flaw on the side I chose to have on top.  I probably wouldn't order this particular one again.