I ordered the rustic walnut and I could not be happier.  The mantel is absolutely beautiful.  It does not look like planks of wood put together.  It looks like one solid piece of wood.  It changed the entire look of my fireplace.  I now like the bricks and don't want to change them anymore.  I would highly recommend this mantel if you are looking for a piece of distressed wood for your fireplace.  Another great purchase from Wayfair.