100% absolutely pleased.  I found them pricey, however, the vintage lamps they will go on make it worth the price I paid.
I was concerned about measuring, and the hardware (spider, screw on etc.) but Melissa helped me.  Fabric is beautiful.
I will remove the cold trim on the old ones and add them to the beautiful shades.  Service was exceptional, arrived in perfect condition days before estimated time. Showing vintage lamps.  Keeping new ones in boxes, moving soon.