Let me first say that I dont typically write negative reviews, but then I do think its important to make others aware when something is clearly of poor craftmenship so as to prevent others from dealing with the same issue.... with that said, these shelves were a disppointment. One was fairly solid, but the other was clearly put together incorrectly, and it somehow still passed inspection. I have included photos so you can see for yourself. In addition, they are clearly two different stains on the two shelves as well, one is a yellow pine, and the other a walnut brown.  Nothing about these was worth keeping. Wayfair was a gem however, and did refund my purchase so I could find a suitable replacement.