Perfect. I ordered 3. They were all the exact same. There seemed to me many mixed Reviews on the quality. It is the best quality item I have ever recieved from wayfair. I was a little afraid it would be cheap feeling. It is not. The glass is a smoky antique look. Again.. All glass was the same. The metal is a goldish antique bronzey look. The metal is smooth. It is heavy. I am very pleased with this purchase. Can't wait to get them hung.