Pros I like the shape and the elegant design. 
Cons The Black shade isnt dark enough. Which makes it look cheap.
Two issues with the hardware. First the pull on the gold lamp is silver. Very Dissapointing considering those two shouldnt mix. Also they make a harsh  tink noise when they hit the body of the lamp. Which is annoying since they regularly get slid around on the bar. Ill keep them but there shortcomings are not ideal.
Might be better in a different shade or finish.