This tile is a great addition to my 1920s bathroom.  The pattern was hard to find, so I was very happy to see it here.  The boxes were well packed, with each sheet of tile separately shrink-wrapped to sturdy cardboard.  One box had tiny chips and defects on every sheet -- not damaged in shipping but seemingly an issue in manufacturing.  I discovered it when we were about to lay the tile.  Called Wayfair, and they were wonderful!  A very helpful, understanding customer service rep got me a replacement box of tile by the next morning!  Thank you so much, Wayfair.  You saved my bathroom project from yet another delay.

Pros: Nice matte finish, not too shiny; good value; looks like the original from the 1920s
Cons: Wish there were more colors available