Very thin, and doesn’t have as many parts that help hold it down. And where the straps are to hold it down, it looks like the plastic was burned. Seems cheap and doesn’t have an umbrella hole but I think that is ok for winter storage. I don’t think it will hold up long, but for the price, I just needed something that would fit our very large table. If you’re looking for something heavy duty, this is not it, but does the job ok so far. I am happy with it for the price.