New: I have all 3 of these installed.  Look alone is 5 starts. Lighting is 2 starts, so if lighting is important for you, do not buy this fine.  Functionality wise, I will give it a 4, I does move air, but it sometimes make sounds that I wish it didn't. (Old Port) I have not installed these because I am still renovating, but they are the look that I am going for.  I will update the post once they are installed and I have used them.