Very nice looking counter stools.  They seem very sturdy and are comfortable.  I took a star off only because the fabric is not quite tight enough and I find I am smoothing out a little wrinkle now and then but I don't think most would find it a dealbreaker.  Also, there were a couple of flaws (scratches or little gouges) in the wood on the side of one seat but they are not easily seen and I think with a little bit of sandpaper it will be gone. Overall, I am happy with the purchase and I would buy them again.