I ordered both the Skylight by Hickory Hardware in Elusive Golden Nickel (right/top) and the Successi pulls in Vintage Brass (left/bottom). They're virtually the same size, shape and weight, but Skylight won out for me because the finish is a little more smooth (there is some shine but not super high gloss) brushed look. The Successi were nice as well and a heavy brass with a sort of hammered-look texture. Skylight color is a little more to champagne; Successi is a little more yellow like brass, but both very similar. My picture shows the color/finish difference between the two brands.