The shelf is ok. Has a few discoloration spots, but for my use it will not matter. If you plan to show in a prominent place you may want to rethink. Also I read the reviews that said they did not come with screws. They would have been up weeks ago if we did not have a hard time finding a screw. Some said they drilled the metal hanger larger. That's a great idea if you can do it. I should have listened more carefully to the reviewers.