I love the looks of this clock and it fits perfectly in my space.  
However- the packaging was atrocious- thank goodness this clock is made of sturdy metal or I don't think it would have survived shipping.
Also- the minute hand is very loose; it seems to keep time okay but I had to do a lot of adjusting to keep it from hanging up on the hour hand.  
I don't know if mine was a return or what but I feel it should have been in better condition for the price.