This under-the-sink shelf looked like such a wonderful idea and it is! No more ancient bits of cellophane or such way back in the cabinet and no more reaching in with most of your arm trying to be neat as you approach the trash pail. Unfortunately, I'm still trying to figure out how to put it together. The screws don't seem to fit the holes and I couldn't really follow the directions (and there are lots of instructions). I even enlisted help but that didn't work, so I'll keep trying because it is a great idea. If I succeed, there will probably be 5 stars but right now it's 3 for a great and needed idea.