Bought two of these chairs, and I have a few thoughts...
1) They look great.
2) The seat cushion is very firm, but the back cushion is nice a sift. Not a deal breaker.
3) They went together easily, with one exception. The second chair I assembled had an issue with the front leg. The other 3 went on fine, but this last one wouldn't tighten enough and the the lag bolt stripped out and was basically useless. I had to use a bolt laying around in my garage to secure it. 
4) The construction of the arms seems a bit odd. There seems to be a thin wood covering the frame on the arms... when you lean with your weight on an elbow on the armrest, it can crack this thin wood. It doesn't seem to be able to crack all the way down the arm, just in certain areas. Seems manageable, and not overly noticeable once cracked, but it is certainly less than deal. 

All in all, decent  chair for the price. The looks are the selling point.