I just received these chairs.  I think they are great.  I was really surprised by the quality.  I had my table refinished, and I didn't want the original chairs.  I chose these for durability.  There was no assembly; other than attaching the feet on the chairs.  

I am going to get some chair cushions; but only for added color.  The comfort level is fairly decent.  I also added some felt on the bottom for noise.  Not necessary, they are completely fine just the way they are.  

I ordered the chair cushions from Bed Bath and Beyond.  Finding the right size was a bit tricky.