The product is pretty sturdy. It's ok for the price.  The 3 star rating is because some of the shelves and the top of the unit had scratches on them.  There was no damage to the box, but the pieces are packed together with nothing separating them.  If anything is in between when packed, they will scratch.  Didn't complain or ask for a replacement because of the location of scratches.  That would have been different if they were visible on the outside.  One other piece I didn't like were the plastic handles.  I will probably eventually swap those out.  Overall we're happy with it as it fits where we need it and has the depth that we need as well.