Ordered two sets of these in the white. Love the shape for pasta and salads, too, so when you toss your dressing in, lettuce and toppings aren’t falling off. One out of 8 was completely broken and it was easy to request a replacement. Wayfair reached out a couple days later saying that they’d send a completely new set and no need to return the three. The color is pretty with small specks, some slight imperfections in the paint, but nothing noticeable. Love the bottoms. They’re definitely a rougher surface, like a clay pot out of a kiln, but I like the contrast of the two textures. The tan color on the bottom is VERY pretty!