This one created some mixed feelings. It's heavy, solid, and comes in one piece, so that was very positive. However, the reclaimed wood seemed to be of a lower quality than for the similar coffee table we ordered. The wood seemed ancient and brittle, like it was partially rotting and crumbling. Also, some of the planks had come loose during shipping and had to be rehammered into place. Some of the wood did crumble, it was so old. It was fine though, but we decided to stick it into the closet instead of a prominent place in the living room.