I’m very happy with this chair overall. It’s sturdy and comfortable and rocks smoothly. I did not give it 5 stars because I find it to be a back leaning chair. To make it comfortable for me I had to place two patio furniture pillows behind the back cushion to support my back.  This may not be an issue for everyone but I like to sit up straighter so I can use my laptop or iPad. I would buy this chair again and I’m thinking about purchasing a second chair.