I bought this about a month and a half ago.  Everything is so far,so good (I'll reserve giving a 5 star review for a while).  Keeps wine at a good temp, quiet so far, and no problems.  In other words, it does what it's supposed to do.  The bottom shelf (doesn't fully pull out, but it's by design) and second shelf from the top are a little tight, but that really doesn't bother me much.  If everything holds up, I'm not sure how it wouldn't be a 5 star. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]