So far so good! Happy to see that it came with a cover that we have on at all times when not in use. Only reasons I shaved off a star is 1) wish the handle was easier to access when lit, and 2) would be nice if the tray was removable to make it easier to clean, otherwise we just use our shop vac to clean it out. Otherwise does the trick, looks great, and does a good job pulling the smoke up the chimney!