These are so nice. Like... way nicer than I was ever expecting. They are extremely heavy and the metal is so reflective and nice looking. They come nicely packaged, each one super snug in styrofoam so no risk of scratches. The color is a little more on the copper/gold side than yellow gold so keep that in mind if you're trying to match another shade. I gave a 4 because they did not come with their own hardware so I had to use the old screws. Not the worst thing ever, but something to keep in mind when you purchase. Amazing quality for the price.