I checked out all the reviews before I purchased this one for our dinning room, and I totally agree what everybody else was saying. It's great value and have that restoration hardware look. The only minor flaw is that, you could see the uneven gap between the bottom lip and fixture itself. Also,  the bottom lid itself has this funky plastic (like sea shell color). Anyways, you don't see that bottom lid very often since we hang it pretty low (lighting fixture @ eye level).