Ordered a pair and would give 5 stars for one of them. The 2nd one arrived damaged and seemed to have been previously returned. Wayfair customer service was EXCELLENT and immediately shipped a replacement.

Up to that point my rating was 5 stars.

Unfortunately the replacement lamp does not match the tones of the first one, has a few minor chips, and seems also to have been returned.
Since we will not use the lamps side by side the color difference is not crucial and we will keep them.