We really like this bookshelf! In fact it is more than just a bookshelf, it is really a cabinet with bookshelves. The Modern Hickory color is grayish-brownish, and it has a "grain", it's not a flat look. The cabinet area is spacious and overall this has piece a modern look. The only downside is that in a few spots, it was chipped so the color came off. It's a bummer that the main chip is on the front of the cabinet. However, I intend to find a magic marker to color it in and I'll make it work. It did take 1 1/2- 2 hours to put this together, and at times needed 2 people; one person needs to know what they are doing! Overall we are very pleased with how this looks and fits in and meets our expectations.