This wasn't easy to rate. I actually love how the new chairs look in my space and the color pops. The chairs I replaced for these cost much more but were way more comfortable so my rating is based on the comfort of the chairs and not the look. These chairs look great and feel strong but are not soft or comfy so they may not be for long time sitting on the back or buttocks. Some may prefer the firm support. Perhaps as they are worn in they will become a bit more comfortable. They are not for long time sitting in my space but for comfort I would rate a 3 star. If you're looking for a strong chair, firm seat and popping color this chairs just may be for you.