I'm giving this a 3 because this crib is SHORT - as in I'm 5'3" and the top part comes to my hips. Granted, this is my first baby and I have no idea what a "good" crib is (what if it's too tall, will it hurt my ribs, etc) but this almost looks odd. I did compare the specs to other cribs before purchasing and this one is about 3 inches shorter than some of the other, pricier cribs. I wouldn't think that 3 inches would make such a visual impact but it does. You get what you pay for, I guess.

Other than that, it was super simple to put together and the quality seems to be good.

Trying to wait it out and decide on what to do since I have time - may just give it to my mom to keep at her house.