I only ordered these because they were a good deal in the open box, but they were packaged exceptionally well and in good shape.  Some reviewers said they looked like seconds, that they were dull instead of vibrantly colored, or that the pattern was off, but mine are perfect and very brightly colored.  I have been very impressed with Wayfair in every way.  This particular pattern is a bit more whimsical (cartoonish) than I prefer, but I gave it 5 stars because I don't feel I can ding Corelle for a pattern solely on the fact that it isn't my particular taste.  After all, that's why there are different patterns to choose from.  For those folks that said the pattern is off, I did think it looked that way myself, but it is identical to the pictures, which also look "off."  It sort of looks like they made a printing/painting error.  I went to the Corelle site and they also look "off," so they are meant to look like they were watercolored.  For me, the pattern is...meh.