Rating is based strictly on cost vs value.  The fit, finish, and engineering of this product does not match similar IKEA or Scandavavian Design items.  The engineering is not as sophisticated and the materials are not as heavy.  For example there are exposed screw heads on the exterior sides of the chest that are covered by plastic caps.  With that said, the chest fit our needs for the price.  I would not pay over $160-$170 for this item.  The chest is solid and will hold up to normal use.  It is not difficult to assemble if you can easily follow the directions and you have some mechanical ability and time.  There is a lot of hardware to install and probably more than 125 secrew or fasteners to put together.