I'm very disappointed with this shelf because of the condition upon arrival.  The first picture shows the thickness of a thank card that was included compared to the "protective" foam.  It was as thin as tissue paper, which, I'm assuming, led to a lot of the damage.  I could've included 10 different pictures of damage similar to the second picture.  The third photo shows something bizarre.  There were spots that had a sandpaper like finish rather than a smooth finish.  Fortunately, wayfair has a great customer service department.