I purchased two of these end tables.  One I would give a 5 star rating; one 3 1/2.  The first was in perfect condition; the second has some kind of manufacturers defect in the top.  The item has a pull out tray above the drawer.  What has happened is the piece of wood that runs over the tray was cut short and now there is about an inch gap on the right hand side where you can see raw wood.  The nightstands are heavy and otherwise made very well for the money paid.  I think the one I received should have been recalled by the manufacturer as one with a defect and never sent out.  The nightstand has a brown and red tone to it.  It would go well with a mahogany dresser.  This problem has been reported to Wayfair and they are contacting the manufacturer.  They have been able to solve past purchase problems and I hope are going to solve this one!