The good:
- I was able to assemble the chair in about 10 minutes!  
- It looks nice.
The bad:
- The metal base was really sharp and nearly cut me
- The chair is too firm.  I bought it for the extra padded support but it is like sitting on a bench
- it is narrow.  While my large body fits in it, the arms seem to close 
- the arms are not adjustable.  they just move as the chair reclines
- The chair is not balanced well on the base and can tip if you lean in a certain direction
- Pulling out the foot rest is awkward

Not the chair's fault but the packaging could be better 
  When I brought it inside from delivery the metal stem of the back was broken through the box and gouged my wood floors.

I will give the chair another week or two to "break in" but overall after a couple days I'm unsatisfied.