The first one had a ding in the top.  They shipped me a new one.  The 2nd one was missing a plastic fitting for a screw in one of the pieces.  Currently waiting for the replacement.  I won't know how it all really looks until I get the new piece. Fingers crossed.  I have to say, Wayfair was super great about reshipping/replacing but disappointed that I was 2 for 2 with issues.