We really like our rug, it came just in time too, we hosted a Family Christmas in our livingroom. I give it a 4 because we really like the price and the color(you know how sometimes when you order online how you choose the color that you like, buy it and when its delivered it turns out not to be the color you thought you ordered. The only negative is, we put heavy books & an ottoman on each corner for about a week, and thankfully two corners of the squared area rug completely laid down, but the other two won't completely lay down flat at all. We're still trying but one of the corners has developed a ripple. Other than these, we will happily buy from Wayfair again in the future.