These carafes are the perfect size for me. They hold a lot but it's not so much that they're heavy or awkward to pour. I think it's great that they come with two lids so you can choose your color or have a spare in case you lose one. The real bonus here is that they're dishwasher safe. I've had so much glassware that's hand wash only that it's a relief to find one I can just toss in the dishwasher.