The shelf arrived in a timely fashion and was not damaged. The shelf has the good quality metal and wood. Assembly was moderately easy (even the screw holes are started for you). Definitely difficult if assembling alone. I am worried about the tighteners and whether I have them tight enough. I haven't put anything on it yet but we'll see!

Pros: Quality materials, looks great, holes for screws
Cons: Difficult to assemble alone, confusing when it is tight enough.