This fridge is working good for us and is very nice looking. The flap on the door is a little noisy but better than our last one. I suppose it goes with the territory of having French doors. It keeps everything cold just like it's supposed to. We like NOT having the through the wall ice and water. We never used the water and getting ice that was very noisy. Plus not having that gives you much more room in the fridge and more door space. Very nice.