We replaced our 40+ year old Kitchen Aide with the Insinkerator Pro Cover Control Plus at our plumber's recommendation. It has been 2 weeks since installation (the plumber did the installation). We are very pleased.
The disposal is very quiet. 
We had a Cover Control disposal in the past and were used to the large cover so no issues there.
There is no rubber "catches" but thankfully our new sink came with a strainer. You need a strainer to catch things like silverware, plastic pieces etc.
The lack of rubber "catches" is the reason for the 4 stars, If those "catches" were in place, the rating would have been 5 stars.