The chairs are beautiful and so comfortable!  We did have a leg on one of the chairs that looks like the finish was scraped or peeling off.  I'm talking to customer service today to see if it's possible to get a replacement.  The only issue we had with the assembly of the chairs is that it was really hard to level them.  My husband was able to get them fixed up and they're just fine, but it did take some effort.  I'd rate the chairs somewhere between a 4 - 5 given the difficulty in getting them level.