Still thinking about this one.  The fabric is super soft, but it doesn't feel like a well made piece.  One of mine did come with damage, but that is not their problem and I'm sure they will make that right.  It is a firm cushion and the swivel is a little tight but that will probably keep me from slinging it around and playing on it!  Since it will be used in a seldom used part of the house, it will probably last me forever.  I was actually going for the 'look' and I got that!