I bought the 8 pc set (this one) and the 4 pc set in the same order. When I first the got 8 pc set (this one), the soap dispenser had cosmetic issues... the "metal" finish on the dispenser top was pitted and the whole dispenser leans at an angle (Pls see photos). But I thought that I'd overlook it and would still use it without returning the item. Then, of course, after the 30 day return period passed, the soap dispenser from this 8 pc set (this one) catastrophically failed - Leaking from under the plunger dispenser and making a mess. Except for the faulty soap dispenser, everything else in both sets are solid and honestly, they are beautiful looking!