I can't fully rate these yet because I have not installed them.  I ordered 3.  The first box I opened, the shelf was damaged (veneer was cracked) and the bag with the screws was opened and screws fell over my floor.  I have not been able to account for all the screws.  The second box I opened - the shelf was in better condition.  However, the lamination on the "wood" is not even.  There are shiny patches and dull patches.  The bag with the screws was not open so all the screws were accounted for.  I'm scared to open the 3rd box so it is still sealed and unopened.