It worked for me because I could modify it to make it lower by eliminating one section of the metal pipe that's about 12".  Of course I had to cut the wire and resplice it, but now it is exactly what I wanted.  I would have hated it if I couldn't modify it.  The quality is minimal and useable but not very stylish.  The lampshade is exactly what you would expect in a lower cost product that comes in a shoe box.  It's rolled up and takes some serious dexterity to assemble.   I wanted to get rid of the table lamp...!  Mission accomplished...1  See photo.