These chairs look really nice, the material is durable, and they clean up well. They have adequate padding and the seat width works for our family (everyone in our household is under 175 pounds, guests that are over 200 pounds have not commented on their comfort). My older boys are tall and they like the seat height on these, some seats are too low for longer legs. 
However, these aren't very family friendly chairs. They work fine if you are sitting straight upright and eating dinner. However, if you like to sit at the table for hours talking or playing games, these aren't the right chairs for you. We often need to  lean back and stretch out our arms or back after playing cards for a few hours. We have actually cracked one chair back and nearly cracked others. So we have started using these chairs only when we have a formal meal and asthetics are more important that being able to sit around chatting and playing games for hours.