These are nice looking, heavy, and sturdy. I purchased the grey and I’m happy with the color of them. The existing fabric is a nice quality and a good neutral color. That being said I reupholstered over it to match my kitchen better. Personal choice. As other’s stated the swing back swivel is tight but I think with time it will loosen up. Overall I’m happy with these. 

The only reason I gave them a four star review is because one of my stools is cracked where the manufacturer screwed through a knot in the wood and the clear finish on the same one has runs and sharp bubbles on it.