I LOVE my new stools.  Exactly the modern/industrial look we were going for, and I was really pleasantly surprised at the craftsmanship.  The wood grain and stain is quite lovely, it's a solid piece of wood the entire thickness, and is carved very nicely.  It's slightly raised around the edges and in the middle, making a snug fit for an average sized bum.  Larger rear ends may not find these as pleasant.  I don't expect them to be comfortable for long periods of time, but it's made out of wood with no back, what do you expect?  Nice slim profile for sliding right under the counter.  Would definitely buy again!  

Pros: craftsmanship, style, quality
Cons: Will likely scratch the floor (haven't tried yet), so will have to find pads that can be hidden underneath the narrow metal bottom.