I have only had this chair for 2 weeks now, so can't give much of a review.  However, that being said, I like the chair.  It arrived on time and in excellent condition (the box was kinda crushed, but didn't affect the chair at all).  The charcoal grey is exactly as pictured and the nail heads look great (and are all securely put in--none loose or protruding).  The fabric is fine.  I don't expect it to last forever (after all, it was only $200+).  It will definitely pull if you have a cat who claws at furniture, but I stick an afghan on mine when not in use for that reason.  My two negative comments are first, it is very stiff.  I assume, with use, that will change.  The second is that it sits more upright than I had hoped.  Not uncomfortable, but also, not easy to slouch in.  Overall, I do like the chair and would recommend it to anyone wanting a chair with a small footprint.

Pros: No assembly needed, small footprint, decent chair for the price
Cons: Sits very upright.