These are nicely made; fabric is nice.  HOWEVER, the quality control is not good.  Not Wayfair's fault.  There are black spots and smudges on the right side of the curtain - it looks like the dye used on the turtles.  Sadly, its where the curtain is solid white and they are very visible - looks like mold.  Wayfair has replaced, but the 2nd was worse than the 1st.  I'm trying one more time because I already purchased coordinating items.  If these are seconds, they should be listed as such.  It's not a cheap shower curtain, so it should not arrive with paint spots.