3.5 stars actually...Does it hold wine? Yes. However, the wall connecting L brackets are built such that it is very difficult to screw them into the wall when connected to the wine rack unless you have REALLY small hands or a really long drill bit. So -1 Star for that. The slots for the wine in each row are good for the narrow style barrels but if you have the larger barrel bottles that is popular in Chardonnay and Pinot Noir they will not fit too well. So - 1/2 star for that. Finish and welds were good.