I almost returned these chairs because they arrived before the rest of the pieces in the set and I didn't like the way they looked. However, once the rest of the set arrived, I realized they look quite good. They are sturdy without being too heavy. What I don't like is the finish. I'm not sure why it is so different though I suspect it has to do with all of the reviews referencing splinters when sitting in the chairs. The ones I received would never give you splinters but they were finished in such a way that they almost looks plastic. I almost wish they were just as rough as the dining table and sideboard. At the end of the day, they look amazing with the set. I'm only giving it four stars because I don't love the finish as much as the other pieces.