This chair MAY be worthy of 5 stars, but it's 4 for me only because of my preference. It is a beautiful chair, well made, and sturdy. The only reason for docking a star is because the chair is SO deep. If you're into that, then it's perfect. When I sit all the way back, my feet don't touch the ground. I'm 5'5, so not super tall, but not short either. I solved the issue with a lumbar pillow behind me.