Really, 4.5 stars -- very comfortable, my husband and I got matching ones since we're still working from home for many more months. They are solid and comfortable; we both go 8+ hours all week and don't have any complaints. We are not huge people, and I could see how very tall folks might want a larger chair. The yellow is more of a chartreuse, and gold accents complement nicely. Husband's chair lining is slightly ripping at the top corner after 3 months, which should be an easy fix with thread and needle, but the reason for which I'm taking off 1/2 a star.