I bought these lamps a year ago and waited to review them because I wanted to make sure I still am happy with the quality: I am indeed still very pleased with them.  The metal hasn't tarnished and the lamp shades still look great.  I was looking for tall lamps that would balance a large headboard and these are a perfect fit beside my bed.  For the price, considering you can spend 2 - 3 times more for similar styles, these are a good buy.