This was a good and sturdy product that looks pretty decent.  My biggest complaint is that there is a gap about 1/4" - 1/2" (in some places) between the end of the glass bottom and the edge of the cylindrical shade, which allows you to see the bulbs (which I personally cannot stand).  However, it does match the wall sconces that I also ordered fairly nice (pictured), and I don't particularly plan to use it for light anyway.