Met minimum requirements. I wanted a narrow sofa table and this fit the bill.  
Two is the pieces had blemishes on them. I did not complain because delivery was incredibly slow/late and I didn’t want to wait for a replacement   This table is  placed between the sofa and a window so it is out of sight.   The borders along the bottom shelf did not have pre-drilled holes so I installed them incorrectly the first at time and had to redo it.  
The instructions on how to put this together were terrible. It took much longer than it should have.