Just kind of "meh" from me. This comes in a comically small box, so it needs to be completely assemebled, including the shade.  It looks pretty good, but if you're sitting near it, you can see where the shade velcros onto itself, which looks cheap.  I really had to crank on the threaded joints to get the shade to be directly above the base.  I was worried I was going to break something and I still don't think it's centered.   But it works.  And I like the style.