Giving 5 stars for Wayfair's customer service and helping me get the perfect solution. 4.5 stars for the stools overall -- for the price, the quality is a bit better than expected, however some of the stitching was undone on a seat, which I fixed with needle and some glue reinforcement. 

Initially I purchased the Camel colour, which was a darker/redder tone than expected. I then ordered the Dark Brown, which is a "distressed" finish, but looks more mid-Grey to the eyes, with mild dark brown here and there. Photos added, because I think the trickiest thing about the stools is the colour. Otherwise the frames are solid, and this height is perfect for a 36" counter table. Wayfair was great in helping me swap the chairs without hassle.