We've purchased other grills now and again but they never perform like the Weber. It is, simply, far and away the best. The 18" works great for two to 4 people, which is what we almost always need. The larger one works great as well, but it uses a great many more coals than you need for just a couple of steaks or a few hamburgers. I recommend buying the ash catcher - helps make the whole experience of charcoal grilling easier and neater. It isn't expensive. And it is a snap (literally) to install.