I got this one sale, it was not listed as open box. However since the fan was partially put together, someone had opened it. Which made it MUCH harder to put together as I'm looking for pieces which are already put together. 

This fan is cheap. The blades are a very thin lightweight plastic. The 'high' setting is a 'low' on most other fans. Changing the settings from L-M-H makes a very very very loud beep. 

That said it moves air and oscillates. And it's a cheap fan because ...it's a cheap fan. It is what it is. So that 3 stars just indicates ...it's okay.