The five stars are for what is truly a beautiful piece. I am happy with the purchase and feel that the ottoman is great quality for the price. It's sturdy, comfortable, and well made. 

One complaint that I have is about the assembly -- the ottoman comes with its feet and the hardware to attach them packed inside the storage compartment. When I opened the plastic bag that was supposed to have the hardware, it was missing 2 nuts and the allen wrench to screw the feet in place...not that helpful. That issue not withstanding, assembly was simple and quick.