Since I only just received this set yesterday, I'm giving it 4 stars.  It's beautiful and comfy!  It's a bit on the light side, which is one of the reasons for 4 stars, but time will tell.  Im also unsure how the cushions on the ottomans will stay in place since they simply lie on top without any way to secure them.  It was packaged well and arrived undamaged and all of the pieces were there.  I can't wait to use it on my patio at the beach!