The short review:  Completely satisfied!
The long review:  The 2 colors I was interested in were not available to view on-line.  I called customer service and the rep emailed color swatches to me and described how they looked on her computer.  She offered to place the order via phone and the process was quick and easy.   Wonderful customer service. 
The cushions were scheduled to arrive the 9th or 10th I think, but arrived early on the 3rd !  Early delivery!
The color is what I expected, the quality is better than I expected based on the price.  I was afraid the fabricdye would have an unpleasant odor as is so often the case, but the odor was minimal.  
This was my first order with Wayfair but it won't be the last.